Harvard University, Cambridge, MA., USA
Face Recognition plus Composite Creation
-
Eigenfaces (Turk & Pentland 1991)
-
Uses PCA to compress images to a low dimensional space of small set of basis vectors called eigenfaces.
-
Location in eigenface-space determines the distance between images.
-
Distance from a query image can be used to specify a sort order on a database.
-
Composites
User Study Goals
-
How well does the eigenface metric correlate with users' assessments of facial similarity?
-
Given whatever level of correlation there is between eigenfaces and human users, what search strategies make the best use of it?
-
Are the composites helpful?
Prototype System Overview
-
Uses eigenface engine and 4500 image database from Photobook (Pentland, Picard, Sclaroff - 1994).
-
Queries are either database faces or composites.
-
Composites are constructed by recombining parts from images in the database.
-
Interim composites may be used for retrieval and interim retrieval results may likewise be used to update an evolving composite.
Composite Creation
-
Random generation and feature editing
Register Mental Image
View 100 Random Database Faces
System Generates 10 Random Composites From User's Choices.
User Produces a Composite Via Manual Editing
Evaluation Post-mortem
-
image score = number of image inspections required to find target if that image is used as a query.
-
strategy score = number of image inspections required to find target using that strategy.
-
Determine image scores for each of users':
-
Top five database choices
-
Random composite choice
-
Final edited composite
-
Which strategies elicit the best average scores over all subjects?
Best and Worst Case Expected Strategy Scores
-
Worst Case : sequential search on 4500 images --expected strategy score is 2250.
-
Expected image score of closest of N random selections is ~(DatabaseSize/N).
-
4500/100 = 45, so expected score of closest image in random set of 100 is 45.
-
Best Case: expected strategy score is 100+45 = 145.
Eigenface Best vs. Users' best
Results
-
Mean scores for optimal strategies (within a defined class of "reasonable" strategies)
|
Target 1: Database images only
|
323
|
|
Target 1: Database + Composites
|
260
|
|
|
|
|
Target 2: Database images only
|
677
|
|
Target 2: Database + Composites
|
482
|
Conclusions
-
Eigenface correlation with users' similarity metric exists, but is far from perfect.
-
Composites definitely help.
-
Hybrid search strategies that use both composites and database images as queries appear to be most successful.